Doris Latimore Johnson
If I had not read of the controversy, I would not have known of the book. The sample introduced a story that is well-crafted, riveting in general. From real-life I have met people whose experiences are reflected there. I reserve the right to come to my own opinions. I've read Mein Kampf, The Bible, Uncle Tom's Cabin, The Quran, and the angry poetry of The Souls of Black Folk. Some stayed on my shelf and others not. How else can we judge for ourselves if we don't read? --- why so many Google User as reviewers here?
25 people found this review helpful
Book Bruin Kim
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
4.5 stars I will admit that what initially drew me to American Dirt was the beautiful cover. It made me wonder what story was inside. From the very first chapter I was riveted by the characters and compelling storyline. My heart was racing and many times I found myself holding my breath waiting for the other shoe to drop. I was lucky enough to receive both an audiobook listening copy and reader copy of this book, so I was able to completely immerse myself in Lydia and Luca's journey. My heart broke over and over again, as each character in the story recounted their tragic pasts and also endured unimaginable heartaches and setbacks throughout the novel. Through every hardship though, there was a glimmer of hope. There were so many amazing secondary characters, but Soledad and Rebeca's story was especially poignant. It was brought so vividly to life by Yareli Arizmendi's outstanding narration. She was able to voice each character uniquely (male or female, young or old) and conveyed so much emotion in her performance. The writing was engaging and the story was well paced overall. I did find that the ending felt a little too drawn out, however, and that some of the concluding events felt too in your face/over the top at trying to illustrate the dangers facing migrants. There has been some controversy regarding this not being an own voices novel, but I found American Dirt to be a gripping piece of fiction. Overall, this was a heart pounding page turner that I won't soon forget. Audiobook Review Overall 4.5 stars Performance 5 stars Story 4.5 stars *I voluntarily read and listened to an advance copy of this book. Many thanks to Libro.fm and Macmillan Audio*
37 people found this review helpful