Paul Wight
By no means a bad story, this book needs work. Firstly, the overuse and
misuse of commas. It's clear an editor has cleaned a lot of this up by the
correctly-placed semicolons, but still commas are rampant. Secondly, the
"false pretences" of the title and the cover art: this book is NOT about an
airship named Goliath. The airship's role in the tale is disappointingly
very small. It's actually a story about stolen nuclear weapons and an
attempted coup in Russia. The third issue is the fragmentation and
confusion of the first several chapters. Each introduces new characters, in
a new location, with new priorities. There is no early linkage in the
events, and no reason to get to "like" any of the characters. Fourthly, the
sheer "ordinariness" of the story makes it a real slog to get through.
There is nothing refereshing or new -- the theme is stale.
2 people found this review helpful
Tristan McKenzie
Great story. Had to keep reading; couldn't put it down. This is not my usual genre, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. Strong male characters with a little humor mixed in and some really really bad guys. Highly recommend; you won't regret it.
11 people found this review helpful
Dave
I thoroughly enjoyed Goliath. The story takes twists and turns with some excellent set pieces. The story is action packed as a rescue mission gets more and more serious. This is a well written story, if you are in the mood for a well written, action adventure - Grab Goliath and settle in, you wont be disapointed.