Jessica Irwin
A passionate 'Gone With the Wind' fan, such as myself, might not enjoy the liberties Mr McCaig took with the story of Scarlett and Rhett Butler. I enjoyed the idea of a book that paralleled their story, but I missed Margarett Mitchell's prose and accuracy and detail in building her characters. I don't feel like this version of Scarlett, Rhett, Ashley or Melanie were as true as those in the original works. I much prefer the other sequel, 'Scarlett' to this particular version.
5 people found this review helpful
A Google user
This book was an absolute waste of my time and money. A totally "unbelieveable" Rhett and did not even "align" with GWTW, facts stated in GWTW about Rhett.
I only finished reading it so I could truthfully say I had read it. Loaned it to another "southern" woman to read and she stopped at chapter 2.
the actual rating I wold have given it had it been available was a MINUS 5.
Beverly k Ivie
I read GWTW,,@ SCARLETT,, afterwards this book and I must say ,,I was disappointed,, it seems both of the ladder books where not similar in the ending as I thought it should have been ,, I am sorry I bought and read the last 2 books ,,I don't think I'll ever b able to enjoy GWTW again ,,seeing how much the 2 ladder books end so differently ,, DISAPPOINTED!!!!🙄😞😦😩